Nickelback wins copyright lawsuit over "Rockstar"

"Rockstar" does not infringe on an earlier song titled "Rock Star" simply because they share similar themes about the rockstar lifestyle.

MSN reports that a federal appeals court has dismissed a copyright lawsuit against Nickelback, ruling that the band's hit song "Rockstar" does not infringe on an earlier song titled "Rock Star" simply because they share similar themes about the rockstar lifestyle.

The case centered around claims by Kirk Johnston, lead singer of Texas band Snowblind Revival, who argued that "Rockstar" copied "substantial portions" of his earlier song. However, both the district court and the appeals court disagreed.

The key argument from the appeals court was that Johnston failed to prove the two songs were "strikingly similar." They pointed out that the shared themes of "making lots of money," "connections to famous people," and "references to sports" are simply common clichés associated with the rockstar persona, not unique elements protected by copyright.

The court also highlighted the lack of evidence demonstrating that Nickelback had access to Johnston's song, a crucial element in copyright infringement cases. While Johnston argued his band and Nickelback operated in similar circles, the court deemed this "mere speculation" and insufficient to establish access.

While the song "Rockstar" has received criticism, it was commercially successful, reaching No. 6 on the Billboard Hot 100. Johnston's legal team expressed disappointment with the ruling and suggested they might explore further options.